Are We Teaching Content Or Stretching Student Thinking?

Dec 19, 2023 | Shift

Are We Teaching Content Or Stretching Student Thinking?

by ThoughtStretchers Staff

One critical question to consider in education is whether we are primarily teaching content or actively engaging in stretching student thinking. While both elements are undoubtedly important, striking the right balance between the two can profoundly impact the quality of education students receive.

The Content-Centric Approach

Traditionally, education has often been content-centric. In this model, educators primarily focus on delivering facts, theories, and information to students. The goal is to ensure that students acquire a specific set of knowledge and skills deemed essential for their academic and professional development. This approach has its merits, as it provides a structured framework for learning and helps students build a foundational understanding of various subjects.

However, there are potential drawbacks to a content-centric approach. It may promote rote memorization and discourage critical thinking. Students may become passive learners who merely absorb and regurgitate information without truly understanding its significance or application in the real world. This approach may also struggle to adapt to the fast-paced changes in our society, where the relevance of specific content can quickly become obsolete.

The Thinking-Centric Approach

On the other hand, the thinking-centric approach prioritizes cognitive skills, problem-solving, and critical thinking. It aims to develop students’ ability to analyze information, think creatively, and adapt to various situations. In this model, educators act more as facilitators, guiding students through the process of exploring concepts and ideas, rather than just delivering information.

This approach encourages active engagement, curiosity, and a deeper understanding of subjects. It empowers students to think independently, ask questions, and develop analytical and problem-solving skills. These skills are not only valuable in academia but also in the real world, where the ability to adapt and apply knowledge is essential.

Striking the Balance

The question of whether we should prioritize content or thinking is not an either/or scenario. Ideally, education should find a delicate balance between the two. Here’s how we can achieve this equilibrium:

  1. Content as a Foundation: Content remains a crucial element of education, providing students with the foundational knowledge they need to explore and understand more complex concepts.
  2. Thinking Skills Development: Equally important is the cultivation of thinking skills. Educators should design learning experiences that encourage critical thinking, problem-solving, and creativity. This can be achieved through activities like group discussions, debates, and project-based learning.
  3. Real-World Application: Encourage students to apply what they learn in real-world contexts. This helps bridge the gap between theory and practice and reinforces the relevance of the content.
  4. Flexibility and Adaptability: Recognize that the content itself may need to evolve to remain relevant. Curriculum should be updated to reflect current trends and developments.

The question of whether we are teaching content or stretching student thinking is a crucial one. A well-rounded education should aim to strike a balance between providing students with essential content and nurturing their thinking skills. By doing so, we can empower students to not only absorb knowledge but also apply it effectively in the real world, fostering a generation of critical thinkers who can adapt and thrive in an ever-evolving society.


ThoughtStretchers Education Podcast
ThoughtStretchers Education Podcast

What Is Social Emotional Learning?

What Is SocialEmotional...

What Is Project Based Learning?

Project based learning is an instructional approach that revolves around the creation of a product, using inquiry to identify what students need to know and learn in order to do so successfully.

8 Strategies to Boost Critical Thinking

As we strive to prepare our students for an ever-evolving world, prioritizing the cultivation of critical thinking skills is a powerful step toward their success and empowerment.

Four ‘Circuit Breakers’ That Disrupt Student Inquiry

Creating a classroom environment where the stakes for students don’t feel quite so high, especially when exploring sensitive issues, is crucial. It can help them ask better questions and enjoy intellectual “play” in a way that ultimately leads to deeper thinking and more curious exploration of ideas.

PBL Research: A Guide to Project Based Learning

Learn about project based learning and research in education. Discover the benefits of PBL and how to implement it in your classroom. Get insights from the latest research on PBL.

How To Teach For Surface, Deeper, and Transfer Learning

John Hattie’s body of work suggests that surface learning is the foundation for deeper learning, transfer learning is crucial for success in the real world, and deeper learning is facilitated through inquiry teaching.

ThoughtStretchers Education Podcast

We'll be launching our ThoughtStretchers Community very soon!

Join our email list and you'll receive updates about the launch and events and more as we grow. 

*note, this is different from our main ThoughtStretchers Education email list which is focused on our professional development work.

You have Successfully Subscribed!